A rare and exceptional opportunity to create a custom waterfront estate in Rye! Set on 1.73 acres in sought-after Greenhaven on a private cul-de-sac along the shoreline, this direct waterfront Tudor Revival features its own dock and private sandy beach, with sweeping views down the Long Island Sound. A broad, level lawn and terraced gardens run down to a stone seawall and natural rock ledges at the water's edge. From passing harbor boats and distant bridge lights illuminating the evening sky to spectacular sunsets over the water, the ever-changing scenery offers a captivating backdrop throughout the day and across the seasons. Shifting tides, changing weather, and the natural beauty of the Sound make every view uniquely memorable. Featuring fully approved comprehensive renovation plans by renowned Cardello Architects, this extraordinary offering allows the next owner to bring a remarkable vision to life without the time and complexity of navigating the architectural design and approval process. The proposed Shingle-Style Colonial offers approximately 6,398 square feet, with five bedrooms, six full and two half baths, and beautifully proportioned living spaces across three levels. Cedar-shake roofs and shingled walls rise from a fieldstone base, complemented by a striking stone chimney. A two-story wall of glass fills the entry hall with natural light, while a covered porch wraps toward the waterfront. Facing the Sound, expansive windows and a columned loggia connect to a stone terrace with an outdoor kitchen, dining area and oversized custom spa. Above, a full-width second-floor balcony captures sweeping water views. Generous gathering spaces, private accommodations and a seamless connection to the outdoors accommodate both everyday living and entertaining. An attached three-car garage completes the design. Or, for those drawn to the property's historic character, the existing 1928 stone and half-timbered Tudor Manor offers approximately 8,800 square feet, with five bedrooms, five full and two half baths. Distinguished interiors include a white marble staircase and floors, a living room with a grand carved marble fireplace, and a banquet-sized dining room. Restore the historic Manor, bring the approved Shingle-Style Colonial to life or explore a design of your own. With expansive grounds, a spectacular direct waterfront setting, a private beach and dock, and convenient access to the vibrant Village of Mamaroneck as well as the City of Rye, this exceptional property offers the opportunity to create a legacy home along one of the Sound Shore's finest stretches of coastline. An unrivaled opportunity on the water.
Listing Details
$4,595,000
Active
Single Family
1067297
11/5/2026
8 Day(s) Ago
Property Details
2 Shore Road
Rye
NY
10580
Westchester
8,801
5
5 full, 2 half
12
3
Tudor
Finished
Partial
Stone
1928
Location Details
1.73 Acres
Back Yard, Front Yard, Landscaped, Level, Near Golf Course, Near Public Transit, Near School, Near Shops, Sprinklers In Front, Sprinklers In Rear, Stone/Brick Wall, Waterfront
Attached
Yes
Yes
School Details
Rye Neck
F E Bellows
Rye Neck
Rye Neck
Heating, Cooling, & Utility Details
Hot Water
Public
Septic Tank
Wall/Window Unit(s)
Amenities
Awning(s)DockLightingFirst Floor BedroomBuilt-in FeaturesCeiling Fan(s)ChandelierCrown MoldingDouble VanityEntrance FoyerFormal DiningGranite CountersHigh CeilingsNatural WoodworkPantryPrimary BathroomRecessed LightingSound SystemSpeakersStorageWalk Through KitchenWalk-In Closet(s)Wired for SoundPatioSoundWater AccessWaterfrontBay Window(s)Oversized WindowsWall of Windows
